CERIAS Tech Report 2004-59 ON THE PERFORMANCE OF GROUP KEY AGREEMENT PROTOCOLS

Group key agreement is a fundamental building block for secure peer group communication systems. Several group key management techniques were proposed in the last decade, all assuming the existence of an underlying group communication infrastructure to provide reliable and ordered message delivery as well as group membership information. Despite analysis, implementation and deployment of some of these techniques, the actual costs associated with group key management have been poorly understood so far. This resulted in an undesirable tendency: on the one hand, adopting sub-optimal security for reliable group communication, while, on the other hand, constructing excessively costly group key management protocols. This paper presents a thorough performance evaluation of five notable distributed key management techniques (for collaborative peer groups) integrated with a reliable group communication system. An in-depth comparison and analysis of the five techniques is presented based on experimental results obtained in actual local-and wide-area networks. The extensive performance measurement experiments conducted for all methods offer insights into their scalability and practi-cality. Furthermore, our analysis of the experimental results highlights several observations which are not obvious from the theoretical analysis.